Novels of Revolutionary France, from Dickens to Mantel
A reading path through 1789 to 1794 in three books, from the familiar to the strange
By the Editor10 November 20262 min read3 books
This site earns from qualifying purchases as an Amazon Associate and Bookshop.org affiliate, at no extra cost to you. Every book here was chosen by hand. How this works
Novelists have been writing the French Revolution since before it was over, and the result is a shelf that ranges from Orczy’s costume adventures to serious literary fiction. Most lists mix them up. This one does not try to be complete. It picks three novels that approach the same five years from three distances and reads best in a particular order.
The order matters because each book assumes something the one before it gives you. Dickens gives you the legend. Miller gives you the city before the legend. Mantel gives you the people, by their first names, and takes the legend away.
The one everyone has half read. Dickens wrote it from seventy years’ distance with Carlyle open on the desk, and it is melodrama of the highest grade: the storming of the Bastille, the knitting women, the final speech. Read it first for the shape of the story the other novels assume you know.
Paris, 1785. A young engineer is sent to clear the overflowing cemetery of Les Innocents, and the book is about a city that can smell its own past rotting and does not yet know why. Miller never mentions the Revolution. It hangs over every page. The best novel of the years just before.
Mantel’s first great book and her longest, following Danton, Robespierre and Desmoulins from provincial childhood to the scaffold. It is gossipy, funny and then unbearably sad, and it treats the Terror as a story about friends who cannot stop. Read it last, when you know the names; then it is the one you will remember.
Also considerHilary Mantel’s essay on writing it, in Mantel Pieces (Fourth Estate, 2020).
Read in this order the three books form one story: the legend, the city before, and the people inside the event. If you want to keep going, the obvious fourth is a history rather than a novel, and Simon Schama’s Citizens is the one that reads most like fiction. It will get its own guide in the Big Ideas section.
English readers know French literature mainly through its 19th-century dead. These seven novels, all published this century and all in strong translations, show what French fiction has been doing since: family sagas, social noir, a Goncourt-winning thriller and a Nobel laureate’s collective memoir.
Before you spend a month with Edmond Dantès you have one decision to make: which English text. The modern Penguin translation, the Victorian text in cheap and collectible editions, one honest abridgement and the audiobook, compared.
Haussmann’s boulevards, the first department stores, the barricades of 1832 and the dancers at the Opéra: the Paris of the 19th century is the most written-about city in fiction. Four French classics in strong modern translations and two recent novels, ordered by decade.
22 November 20263 min read6 books
The Monthly Reading Dispatch
One letter a month. Five books, one translation note, no noise.